Should IR be privatised or run with European staff?

Signed 45/3000

Online Signatures: 45

MP, minister f state

mosvm@mea.gov.in

The complaints on the Indian railway are at its peak. there is no one really attending to it worth while. Only FIRST AID is carried out. since the people who use railways try to forget the problem once they have completed their travel is becoming a manure for the LAZy and irresponsible staff that decorate the railways all over India.
They are used to it and the tradition is passed down to the new recruits.
there is one solution to revamp the railways. Terminate thousands starting from the top down till the railway stations. replace them all for a few years with experienced EUROPEAN railway staff on deputation. say a contract for 5 years.
IR will improve to it peak.

The Petition was also marked to:

Sri Piyush Goel
Railway Minister India

- dgrpf@rb.railnet.gov.in

Make Railways BetterJan 16

45 Online Signatures

Viewed by 3707

comments (50)

updates (0)

Shibdas Mallick

Let's ask your organisation to replace you with European officer. Or do you think you are an ideal employee?
Can't you think beyond Europe sitting in India?

I recommend 'Padmabhushan'!!!! in next tern for you. more

Jan 21

Shibdas Mallick

Jan 21

Ramesh Kutumbe

Sir,
I agree with Shri Shankar Desai in that training our own staff with the sense of service is most important.
This must start with retraining present staff but more important and definitely start at recruitment stage. As. a matter of fact, I think this is applicable to all PUBLIC SERVICE recruitment up to level of INDIAN (Adm., Police, Foreign, Auxiliary, etc.) SERVICES. We must select only those candidates who have demonstrated flair for sense of service. All other requirements of education, experience etc. need be checked only after sense of service is satisfactory in Applicant. Probation period should be for two years and recruit should be working in two different divisions for a period of 1 year each. Very close monitoring of work and behavior of the recruit should be done and if not found suitable his/her services should be discontinued.
It is expected that about 10 - 15 % of recruits may be lost this way.

I am inclined to agree with Shri Tarun Kumar Banerjee (Professor) in that to keep constant efficiency, there should be no permanent staff.
RYK more

Jan 18

Gopal Sv

Dear Dilip, I disagree with you. Railways privatization should start in phases and its a necessity. The resources available are under utilized / not utilized at all. Union Govt's Budget cannot meet the Revenue requirements of Railways. Railways being a Govt department, cannot tap the Private funds freely like any other Company. Its a vicious circle. Indians are more efficient and take more stress than any foreigners. this I have experienced being in private sector. How many of the signatories of this petition itself will welcome annual increase of the Fares by 5% p.a. There's a political angle to every action of Railways which is blocking its growth and exploring full potential. more

Jan 18

Sudhanshu Jain

Indian Railway is the life line of India. Govt. should increase investment in it to lay more lines so that trains speed can be increased rather than privatized it. more

Jan 17

Sudhanshu Jain

Absolutely rubbish idea. If after 70 years of independence we are looking for European railway staff it shows bankruptcy of our minds. And so far privatization is concerned one should not think that privatization will bring revolution.
To make railway batter there is need to train them batter and end corruption. more

Jan 17

Related Petition

Train cancelled
My train has been cancelled which is scheduled for 21st February 2023 whose train no. is 15025. And I have to reach urgently Delhi on 22 February 2023. IRCTC should inform before 1 month ...

By Shubham Dixit

/
THINK OF THE POINT-TO-POINT COMMUTERS BETWEEN SATARA AND KOLHAPUR
One will not disagree that, Indian Railways is the cheapest way conveyance of common man of this country. Everyone is aware that during the period of Covid-2019, all train services were terminated ...

By ABDULKARIM SHARIKMASALAT

/
Palwal Delhi Local Train
Dear Chairman Sir from palwal to delhi local trains restored after 2.6 years but all local trains are running late 30 minutes to 1.30 hr both time evening & morning. please maintain ...

By Suneel Vats

/
Bed roll in Train
For a/c passenger ,Bed rolls r not provided in every trains at present.It won't serve the purpose to reduce the Baggage. Examle.if i get Bed roll,travelling from Delhi to Bhopal. And not in re...

By RAJIV KULSHRESTHA

/
Staff irresponsible
Trichy railway station the staff name srini

By Surya Prakash

/
IRCTC - Tatkal Tickets - Regret within 10 minutes
Within 10 minutes of opening for Tatkal booking dated 14.02.2020, the following was shown on the screen today. What is the reason for such quick book via tatkal, should not an investigation be don...

By Venkiteswaran Subramaniam

/
Toilets in Long Distance Express Trains
Many of the long distance express trains are fitted with only Indian Style Toilets in the Upper Class Sleeper Coaches even in the new coaches built by ICF. Use of these toilets becomes extremely di...

By T J Cherian Cherian

/
FACILITIES TO SENIOR CITIZENS
As far as either Senior citizens or wheel chaired passengers concerned, the reaching of platform other than the Platform 1 is a herculean task in all the railway stations. Hence at every over bridg...

By RAMAKRISHNAN VC

/
Make Railway Divyang / Senior Citizen Friendly
Today, a wheelchair bound person can not travel by Railways without facing huge challenges. Ramps are absent at most of the places (Including Delhi). Climbing on to Train itself is a huge task. Als...

By Bhuvnesh Thakar

/
IRCTC monopoly must go. Rlys should not give Monopoly to IRCTC for train tkt booking. It must a
Rlys should not give Monopoly to IRCTC for train tkt booking. It must allow tourism ministry or any other authority to start another Tkting App. IRCTC is arrogant , inefficient and costly. Its e...

By MADHUKAR SHETH

/