Login / Signup Show Tiles Close

Krishnakumar Srinivasan

GST rate

One of my client is a manufacturer of Aluminium Casting for which HSN code is 7616. They are supplying the components to manufacturers of tillers and tractors. The vendor has raised the purchase order for my client in which they have mentioned HSN code 8432 for tiller unit with GST rate of 12% and HSN code 8708 for tractor unit with GST rate of 18%

I want clarification from you whether the vendor is correct in charging different rate for the aluminium casting based on their final product and parts. I have given below their reply for the above more  

Viewed by 952
View all 13 comments Below 13 comments
Shyam Shrivastava
[ ]( # ) [ ]( # )   [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/W2e5eLynzoIaHJbVOgn7WBKpyMQwNUrOdWNwqkpWoLxS80azsbs6CVobZkbAe6WR2pnRGscZprt2-C8t_gxpIF6S3WDrKfdj6XRghLBWq-C47OY6ksO9mmbE0FsTqCJTfuJuC8SN-l4gfZ_nQq-QICJDEqcpRQIL1GgPlBMa2ovgzkrjVbUiJHqQAn1OOjxTiyHDFP5tTrKEX1lNsmWV62OiWDzADamjrFBsqre0GbcmNbMIAuvRrRQOEg-ARBKFt5P9FdLEdBh7ToDEsGj-aVPNxasRb48IhwH9Y6Safr02ab9JQ5RYXKyNx5j6pTfU571A_YHqjIWKf5mAnJrfvMwdoQRPZ9gtrGGcorBbkkZ9-VmYbA )   [ ]( # ) COMPUTER FOR ONLINE CLASSES [ ]( # ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/mFTB20SalC1mbMt1oxyp3a48jfI_TrZyRvQslxmZs23VR7BnTaZzUDQOKg3D9AT0HXBGFRbYF6Jkg8w-pb75--H32xZUchNOgjNIpX_g_nNo_hY3RUqfjJHbb6XwQPwaeLEITP1jIfSXWDJBU89UY8NODwJqrirVKNIsrtf0WkWi60--71yFBQV9NzY1KWfqUcVpFtoq9B77DYXM6cSMSj6F68Moou39PZl6gjARcyB5sLa3VBdFISUWFBE1hzm178io_GVXDFVv3G3XmVBL84RCPnXXEFEBS-CNEwYw_SFxogGB9zIggCdyT3VaFsXrqdkl9pTL0DoHY4XSdlaTjk39T6RAuyXcBRwJxWfpJ56KmXD9XA ) [ ]( # )   For online classes we are providing a complete set of computer with UPS in following specifications: Monitor 15"; Camera & headphone CPU: 160 GB HDD, 2 GB RAM, Core 2 duo Keyboard, mouse UPS ( Electronic voltage stabilizer ) This complete set we offer pan India for Rs. 21000/- ( All inclusive ) One extra 160 GB Hard disk will be supplied free of cost within 5 years, if present becomes in sufficient. All carry "M.I.'s" 1 year warranty.       [ ]( # ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/SoO0StJ4Yzyo_mJWe85rs--W0u8TRCUQZQ7iXSo_2CwJFfQl4Bxpo_QOCIv4yUN7_1LKsLv9HJuOD1QCCLwNzw-1qxjPHIGQ1I9RdoHXzv4wuFf3Fu7OZ4420eNQbE8uB4yF0z7KL2cbUUItyOJujC1idpIc_7_v-Ec9UzDqSSDswzROHfry9lyrBydu261hdpzgQ3u_bmMIl8dF7gGSfElK7xO1UIuIDwz0M7vzRZSU0i_K1TLkGt3lrSagGisY9_ukAUTwStWlT1iEoPI3LVAr6QMCzY88ELkcwi2Yd4IkiIzVEz-eRt79hGtiTbMwIcfeXSJ30cGRYh_LO8JrHFUerDRTzP-3BvMF5AWP_dIP9fiC6g ) We understand the hardships...   Hardships of the parents, hardships of teachers, hardships of every such individual who is now compelled to work from home; be it student or the the professional now computer set is must. we decided to help all such people by providing the complete set including UPS to save your machine for longer life. In comparison to laptops desktop is robust & long  lasting and also cheap & best ! For getting this deal, please click the button below:   [ Button ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/dOhXlmLTPxqwN1pYTFL43Q8p0aAOGqNMoTL8-UBQx8PBIOLt5u4YmagHNVcWu5cNi4N__sT7RJDyIwRWW5kPAQPZx3jq5syFFH0TsH47FrOIL36jNk7YbSxu23TgDeKyhHsyx8AdnZlZExD0wKoM7VNFiro5NqgaO5YTxZtGL3BCtAqqGK4D5vfwBoWyqKZNSgu7kPpGHFA9C1UR4ErYT7q9pXtHNQQ8v0ljtKrT8ZLSJYChX5658W6qWMmUsBAhik7GxftB9JsMxXMNr0O2j85gQA86SsK8Hoh5R0pI294OXcbO3HJWoPiMDx5EAdcaVJYbbIjxG9SXF17b6jOfgHT85EipaQoiaeLs86yjxCImDZQHoQ ) [ ]( # ) [ ]( # )   SIGMA INSTITUTE Delhi Cell: 9899075161 [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/1JrbmIh2w0HqYt_XTJUoqBDbexIHTh9w-KxdnkQrlJ47N6JeyTa8AqN0X-u6TVG939Xdtvhar6NDmNlexaCp3cQuVu8hrI0-WfDtsLL42U8Y4B69LhqUsF4vi2MvS8yLhNprHeT4VhCHbmq7dgjObP6GQwF1YXm9E6fVgmTkH_5Vib1lAdsce1-UCJ53gG0ff5oCGaotZRq9NQJkRDBKd2GZlB2gHa5nc4VS2-Hm25dg3sMUsd0X_v2a7bosEkiuSP-KLmTWrRdu4O6QgKKwhdFNRnZnQCkpEk98J2SS-VaVpTXNDpYwFs77gjxForAK5v_On-N8FCJn1whU7nFOcJFHS2gTkA ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/ZF6JwP-wmID7XYKBOUNlloAxwUTFmgMzRkXknK1kuOBPk9S7q8Wh-N4iuBIw3BpdTA35D7SXaS9W62MpFKZFnv4M6h2JVTK7smh_WfQfAPa8Y2ASOoAOSvVK9l5VqHIuxMXbMt_Na92pUdo7bmPP2FSL99vQvZ3b-tUVYMDEk3A9k7wzAq5odLeE9QQr63yHNkSjvI4PWEuX21Lnf8BFsM86F05hu8EWCtJtbhOTY8htgLNk2YhMAG9Dq8rDkwMMfmVoHek0-yoRLUCGfa1EuKvB3aZaCvfZoQ-dGbT7lERw0ImKe7JLMYkJO2HPZ-nhAwLClpDTjz5WE6Iw3tv5J0NrSQ ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/bQTRX0LQwWUbmfW7psjTmhQMpB5n2gp3aubnoMHgnbUI3GsWQZMX3B1dbp6ygKPnoT22LbnUf0re3TRhc5rOjvyt-YqXfv5QpqT6_unvp800umt7NTyYi918tDpBykCF5Ndh8rSZqv9oeva56ok54G9fq5EKHy0k6_O0jfa9JnCaHAp3-2H9TgVxqdhQbUX0dj0Gnmmcc4hfcim37eKOULOG3w60racFrP6Iu6JmhjEoQtrB72MTdx1uQiM_mIxlq-tOEa2a6ACDapI-uAZlKyq3MVB62fC5JLtJS7HTXhVxipEShqnanRSV95udpHhj6BFwipns6efLPuAVaNCNnhU ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/5ShSZomv_rtvA-nR6ciy5Yrih4mCkdQvRxolrPOc3yTAZ9owQkrGLhyRk50v4oDtIqstJLcGXyWWZ1H5xhN6QYGWHjObng0Rz4ZccL-69YcIeHlrafRtyHgum6foDMpnAAY5ikIrhYpoYWbmgAlBhe0osg17ua_YQVUAHJ8rWre6BUdUVoaL5EitlgV_h_zMOqRYCtz0qPI1rWqrt3qkmLXY6WlloNThwXg5ZfZ9DVSrCqzaE5M3eFllYDIPis5Qd8n3UyJmNSnoTuit1zb_U_4rynQXWB4ConzdlmKzHRmdS03lytb9ihYGFTrb4OU9C8Dw9tG4QyknzDpdyCk8IEPeHTmC_SmKYt0bbfc ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/021jdEfZ2VP4WzFzJm3FUxFnUWmezVMAIFyhexkiEV7-WcrFVySfxFkTRTkyQWRvHSht2GINLI1aIHDeiqZ-YxBSzSUFH2lNOjLYjj9yH51OJmHEEDyYO6DWmF3zK6Mis137uDAEskqLP5yE-w3jC64DIF2swBeYwzsrrGkOcP0y0Lm1dut1f8qmbR8da_jPO_HZLPb5Or9STq1CyHwn3Nj8g-OTAuWAtGBI7djy3RlI9s9GSx1Cwq3jQyW8MEzi7blxWq_Fu-smY6fggAeWdN3GqGDClh08ilotL4qvwPhZbGLjBS-usnBNc9YK5AlnP3WzRKPr1UZoCJJYQ6W8fDKYeavxmA ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/C95CMiLkA9LXFfYW6YwhWKuZ64XrA4lqvw1IAyjACB57Mrsra0a62j-4ydJbxuTZZlglqyNfw5V_9s-TQCCMiL5cL8PZHjHfH6VsAe8bNVM37nCDbftIOnbPdtOvFZWlT_YDQUwX3AXXiLI8bXK4hUFCoLYhtB_EuzO5CIZRQZOg85PTb3dydku1mDQfFbucoBStyURgJDS0bHM9nSunB69Z3ORTtPqCaVKSAK5Cg7cMd4_gn0BYQ0SrHMdlxd4ZVMZwkUzi3WuVrp5wZ3wl4L4DbtOlTrrEnqP5JhsGyXjEoOMo0eJHltaAWpE0UPkkdGeIrK-2J9CqrHy5e1cs4otgW3KYD7KzcJn2cVftYBajmelf3hOU0bESj9VqVyf_lYt1VnaV_fL3MyhE6wc ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/qCp0bzNvBIh0zWOYZjm-49qvJLmsQmUV8iY1tndazQrmg-BYNC5UYH37wdeO9gug_rgjWAcpy_iLRTzpgj1B8I6OzrHjKnE8QytyFtji1QB4auiDNMhbU1TiliGY66rjbiAIb2mq2Zym5HKzW0OqeNpE4ul_BD_XYm0SBqRunf6QcNuDsvEzrBpPbg1p23qhO7mRdML8l51ilWcec_k7b_jo9SGaoCxRp_3mRfTmrXkk8rtdlD-yK3T6o9tzdrJ3r4eHzb3kYeg9AhPIZTxXc94o8yoEfnZRVu4BSSCK_icCrAxYpVzlLwPtmGKVgHCv5UAtl5R0UjWYz4CKbmn5IrQc2do7u_9O2qbThj2f ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/CIbOqMqJu4fmm4K7B44MHcpkixESQq2avUEzK17SDmDdmc2Ye3RqIhTGElIV2HZQWfb7H5FZEKPNr21N_vYSZBcITCIu98m5nCGSk9HGJez4MrGTOMBQQYZT6b5kT6OtrN28islyWCLaqPvX0CyKjbeSORccbydavmtaDl4p0wlw8Bh1-0JX4ITkR8HN1alA40HyaLveGp5oAuaqxtB6ZZb_rD6QSnlgrLQXFfivKJPPhSVaY4qBTORHexS3N5UmP8B64iIR_70bwfXnyITlfiIZtfBgnT6fYB2X51Xxiwa6o2IbOX_pNRXrNh4-NS1frkAIjfSCJgYx5MoBL4neXhkyVEveW1nNPRll )   [ ]( # )   You received this email because you are registered with Sigma Institute   [ Unsubscribe here ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/un/VT801jH4eAxD61ncZ9KJXeMDDoafdua9YciyEp739zwLhVE5ZVAgWu_VblFRguKayO6EzbUpc3MM4ywpAQ6BPrkN67yxC8lq6nqEVwJBHcI2K1SAskLOk7tpIxpchgRUBU0OaDCYii3EfVuycceU9SMznG5c9GprMGEm05FkyA7nBjiFsjHPpLCWYsGReOXsX8l9pouPSC0xUaycnmiGGkeOowg )   [ ]( # )   © 2020 Sigma Institute   more  
Ravi M K
Sir, The HSN CODE depends on the end products application and is grouped under the correct category by GOI. Central excise department will have all these codes and they tell you under which category the item falls. So, tough both the products are aluminium castings, they need not fall under the same HSN. Also, they can attract different % of taxes. more  
S K Virmani
In my view the product to fall in a specific category is to be best choosen by the manufacturer. The buyer of that particular item has to adapt to nomenclature of the supplier to claim input tax credit. The manufacturer cannot name and classify the product based on buyers preference. If that would have been the criteria then the manufacturer will keep on changing name for different type of buyers. more  
P K Mukherjee
Recipient may have a point if the castings are identifiable parts of tiller/tractor. However, if you have been discharging CE duty without any objection from the CE Dept. so far, you may safely continue with 7616. more  
C Suresh Krishna
Manufacturer, is the only person,who can decide/explain Hs code of their product. suggestion of the customer, is just their opinion more  
View 13 more comment(s)
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Corruption in GST

      Time limit for making Refund Application A person claiming refund is required to file an application on the GST Portal in Form GST RFD-01 before the expiry of two years from the “releva...

      By Rajeev Bhargava
      /
    • Illogical

      Car is a fixed asset , it depreciates. If you sell a used car either you make profit or loss. Hence it should be subject LTCG/STCG tax only if you make profit. How is selling a used car misco...

      By Amit Mishra
      /
    • GST popcorn indicative of bigger issue

      The GST hair splitting over Popcorn is but a symbol of how theGovt has spectacularly failed in taming the bureaucracy. In 2014 when this Govt came to power they promised to make simpler laws. And t...

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari
      /
    • GST rules are stupid

      GST rules are most stupid. See how GST varies for chocolate cake based on where you order it from. This government has made a mess out of GST.

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari
      /
    • Get this guys

      Govt consdiering: Recommendations to increase GST on Tobacco and Tobacco products to 35% from 28% Aerated Beverages GST also expected to rise to 35% Govt may consid...

      By Sudesh Rai
      /
    • Corruption in GST

      GST office dont make any gate pass , no security checks . Is this to facilitate people to walk in with cash and gifts for officials. What happens if terrorist gets in .

      By Rajeev Bhargava
      /
    • Taxation is hell

      Indian taxation is truly hell, the average Indian gets paid 20x less than average westerner but pays 10x more for essentials like laptops while 50x for cars. This is literally butchering the middle...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • Corruption in gst

      According to my husband, Corruption in GST starts from registration itself now. Getting told it's impossible to get it done in Delhi without a bribe. You get a query for more docs with t...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • Is there a GST bribe rate card now

      You can get a rate card for everything in gst office Registration 10k Assessment where no tax payable 15 k Refunds 4% This is what a friend is saying. LC Manager must esc...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • GST cancellation

      Nephew had applied for GST cancellation a couple of months back but continues to receive notices from GSTN for failure to file monthly return. His accountant tells him that GST office will not proc...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • 7 years of GST

      7 years post the launch of GST I must tell you that most retail services businesses in India still evade it and Govt has failed to do anything. From ac repair fellow to caterers and from...

      By Sudesh Rai
      /
Share
WhatsApp
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

हिन्दी About Us Citizen Pulse News Trending Team Career Privacy Policy Sitemap Contact Us
© LocalCircles 2025 FB Link Twitter Link
All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)
Send