MY DEAR FRIENDS , HOW WILL YOU FEEL WHEN YOU GET THIS MESSAGE ,

CHOICE OF AT LEAST ONE BERTH NOT MET ,PARTICULARLY AFTER THE AMOUNT IS DEBITED FROM YOUR ACCOUNT .

This happened just now ,when I was booking my tickets back from Tituccchirapally for the 16th Novemebr . Should this not have been flashed before debitting , so that I could have opted for another train .

Now I am forced to cancel this ticket which will cost me Rs.180/ If I book another ticket and I opt for book only if atleast one lower berh given ; and if it repeats again , I will land up paying another cancellation charges .

IS THIS THE ONLY WAY TO RAISE REVENUE FOR RAILWAYS ?WHAT SORT OF CUNNING STRATEGY IS THIS ?

I am helpless as many other rail pasengers / Customers . more  

20191031_192051___20191031072722___.jpg
View all 48 comments Below 48 comments
Why can't a PIL be filed for restrictive trade practice, had booked a ticket costing 240/- of ac cc, had to cancel since immediately realized that date was wrong, railways deducted 180/- rupees towards the same that is 75%+ of the cost of ticket, rules say minimum of 180/- will be deducted, it's should be amended as a % of cost of ticket not exceeding the amounts they want to charge. more  
We faced a similar problem-..We booked tickets from the booking counter exactly four months in advance and allotted upper berths to senior citizens and when I lodged a complaint I received a reply "system - generated allotment " which can not be corrected and you manage with your co- passengers. It was 17th October, by Rajdhani Ahmadabad New Delhi Express. To our utter surprise lots of seats went vacant and few LB were occupied by youngsters .Must thank TC who was kind enough to adjust us without any extra payment which to our experience is next to impossible. On Thu, Oct 31, 2019 at 11:30 PM Jayakumar Daniel wrote: > more  
This is a sorry state of affairs of our railways. Since the railways didn't comply with the directives of the applicant, they should not charge any cancellation fee upon cancellation of the said ticket(s). However, there is no such facility available in the online booking menu, which leaves with only one option of cancellation without asking for the reasons therefor. I would suggest to write back to the railways explaining the situation with a request to forego their cancellation charges as the reservation was done against your mandate. more  
Sir, they havent chareged any cancellation fee while refunding .

But created a flutter as they deducted the money first ,then they flashed

the news saying that your opted berth not met . more  
It appears from your screenshot that you had given that option but ignored in booking system just by informing that it was not met. In that case ticket shouldn't have been booked otherwise what's the meaning of such option. Railway has become one of the most corrupt organisation openly looting people. Such open nexus with agents helping them even by unnecessarily modifying the earlier good working booking site is clear as daylight. Actually in a monopoly state they are least bothered what the common man says. more  
Ms. Hina Manerikar,

It's really socking to see your post and surprised why you are here in this local circle. If you compare everything of present world with that of 50 years back (just because you are 70 years old) and get astonished how things are improving then please be at your present circle and don't enter into this Local circle, which is established to point out for improvement from what's available in present days and not for comparing with that of 50 years back and clap.

While I do agree that Indian Railways handle heavy traffic, please appreciate that's applicable for every department in India. Then in your opinion we shouldn't criticize any wrongdoings and corrupt practices.

It's really funny to see someone is judged based on his/her age (as asked by you and you are in your Seventies so you know everything). For your kind information I am 59 years old Engineer, and come across the transformation from old days technical hand-notes to modern computerized world in my career of 35 years (still going on). So do you think I need your unnecessary interference (god knows what's your intention) supporting what's wrong/corrupt is happening, just because it's better than old days- RIDICULOUS!!.

I have visited about 18 countries during my career (not with political Public money but by my Employer) including the most populated China and seen how the world has improved in last 2 decades, while in India Railways still consider a train running @ 50 KM/Hour (theoretical) as Super-fast and charge extra for that (Oh yes - 50 years back speed was 40 km/hour so be happy). Please spread your access a little wider out of Politics / etc., etc., and then comment please or most preferably refrain from commenting in local circle just to give a politically motivated comment that everything what's happening now!!! is excellent.

I have worked with few Ex-Railway officials in my career and shocked to know how corrupt that organisation is and there are people who even take bribe from their own colleague (of other department) to clear their tour bill / salary arrears etc.

Do you think we are there only to criticize- NO. There were hundreds of suggestions everyday in local circle but who bothers? Criticism is still the best way to highlight wrongdoings/ shortcomings and anybody interested can take corrective measure based on criticism, they don't need detail project report to understand the corrective measures, if interested.

Thanks,







Thanks, more  
Mr. Shibdas Mallick, I think you are being very unfair to the railways. I don't know how old you are, but we in the age of seventies remember how difficult it was to book a ticket and how many hours we spent standing in queues. If you consider that ours is the largest railway system and they are doing a fairly good job and more important they are open to feedback and are constantly trying to improve. I wonder even if any other country can manage such heavy traffic the way we are doing. I am not trying to defend their deficiencies, but we should give credit where it is due. Instead of being just critical suggest corrections and solutions so that they can improve their functioning. more  
MR. MALLICK , I GET THIS FLASHED ON THE SCREEN SOON AFTER THE

MONEY IS DEDUCTED .

I AM REALLY SURPRISED TO NOTE THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE TO SUPPORT

THIS PROCEDURE , INSTEAD OF POINTING OUT THE WRONG METHOD

ADOPTED BY IRCTC OF DEDUCTING THE MONEY FIRST , THEN SAYING WE

ARE NOT ABLE TO BOOK YOUR TICKET . more  
Intimation of 'ticket reservation not confirmed/cancelled' just before 4hrs is not feasible with the present scenario of technical problems such as heavy traffic in internet/transmission towers, poor performance of established communication system, Rly staff being sluggish, careless service, not afraid of disciplinary action by superiors, union interference, poor trained staff, fresh staff being slow , timely unexpected events etc.. Pl excuse me if I support the faulty action. I personally feel that sincerity is weakened by so many factors. The staff should realize the sufferings met due to improper/delayed message. So far I did not encounter such sufferings. If it happens one in thousand ,may be ignored. Outsourcing or handing over to private enterprise is not the solution, absolutely. Upgrading the system to match the present need is lacking, because the network system software is upgraded by soft ware giants at Himalayan cost frequently. It is possible that data entry software staffs are not adequately qualified / or outsourced to an ill equipped contractor. Well, tough time ahead to manage such situation. It is a complex area. more  
What exactly you wanted to say Mr. LAKSHMANAN RAMACHANDRAN and how it is related to Mr.Daniel's post?

As a reply please provide only related messages or post it as a separate message, not as a reply. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • YET ANOTHER MISHAP WITHIN A WEEK: No lives lost or injury or Damage to rail property.

      We take this as increased attention from Indian Railways focusing on the frequent Mishaps. If one notices closely the time of the accidents one aspect emerges clearly that it always happ...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
    • worst level of railway

      Railway was best where there were rare accidents in gap of several years because it was in hand of capable government who was understanding the duly of government. Now there is government of busine...

      By Anil Srivastava
      /
    • Human life safety in transport systems

      IR should also think about safety from all angles, as timely regular maintenance and preventive maintenance , timely replacement of rail tracks and coaches.Life and load bearing capacity of tracks...

      By Satyapal Singh
      /
    • Lucky, no lives Lost this time . It is not a healthy sign for the Railways:

      Lucky, no lives Lost this time, yet another accident . We should march ahead with a healthy outlook. The Railways has gone much ahead in the Signal system by modernizing. Yet this keep...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
    • A plan to keep elders from cabin is looking real agenda.

      After removing discounts to senior citizen , this is just an matter of making people fool. Who is going to verify that whether lower seat is available or not. Moreover, while booking window ticket ...

      By Anil Srivastava
      /
    • Circle expression worked

      Indian Railways has agreed it will reserve lower & side lower berths for Senior citizens, disabled people & pregnant women. 6 to 7 lower berths in sleeper classes, 4 to 5 lower b...

      By SN Mittal
      /
    • Operation from Civil Engineer

      Railway cannot be run by businessman. They are concerned with profit no matter how they are damaging to government property made from tax payers money. The accidents were a rare situation once in f...

      By Anil Srivastava
      /
    • Allotment of Tatkal ticket without any reason is forceful extrotion

      Tatkal quota is nothing by illegal extortion of money. Who is going to verify the need of Tatkal. It can be given if somebody is admitted in hospital and you have to go, take the hospital receipt a...

      By Anil Srivastava
      /
    • Allot tatkal by lottery

      tatkal from the right begining is a big nuisance. People have invented so many jhugads to bypass entire including manipulation by staff and Chinese software. as a result one h...

      By SUBHASH PARAKH
      /
    • How Can Rail Accidents Be Minimized Most Effectively ?

      The Railway Ministry came under scrutiny during the recent Parliament session, as Members of Parliament (M.P.s) raised concerns over the rising number of rail accidents and called for a broader imp...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
    • Too bad dear railway

      Railway is biggest corruption adda. If they are true and honest, lets publish the seat blank coach wise and quota available and fill the same once the ticket is booked with pnr number . The VIP quo...

      By Anil Srivastava
      /
Share
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)